EN

Rome II: determining applicable law in cross-border cases

Read time: 5 minutes

In New Law Journal of 24 February 2017, Kelvin Farmaner of the Forum of Insurance Lawyers and a Partner with Trethowans LLP, Paul Lavelle, Claims Manager of Van Ameyde UK and Charles Dougherty QC of 2TG report on a recent application of Art 4(3) of Regulation (EC) 864/2007 (known as Rome II).

In the case of Pickard v Marshall and Others; Generali France Assurances v Marshall and Others, in which Van Ameyde UK represented Generali, an appeal by a UK insurer to the Court of Appeal has been rejected so that the original decision of the High Court stands. This is thought to be the first reported case in the UK in which Art 4(3) has pointed back to the same law as Art 4(1) and will be interesting for multi-tort cases (such as a motor vehicle pile-up) when determining the applicable law.

The case relates to an accident in France in which an uninsured French car collided with two British nationals as they were standing behind a UK registered car and trailer, while the trailer was being attended to by a French registered recovery truck on the side of a motorway. After hitting the individuals the French car collided with the trailer, pushing it into the UK registered car which in turn was pushed into the recovery truck. One individual was thrown forward by the impact and landed clear of the vehicles and suffered serious injuries. The other was thrown off the front of the French car and the trailer fell on his leg. He died at the scene.

Two actions were commenced in England by the UK victims. The issues were (i) whether French or English law applied to the issue of liability; (ii) if French law applied, whether the UK vehicle and French recovery truck were “involved” within the meaning of the applicable French statute, Loi Badinter, and (iii) whether the MIB was liable under the 2003 Regulations. The Court determined that the applicable law was the law of France.

The decision provides a practical approach to complex multi-part cases subject to the ‘manifestly more closely connected’ test.

Forward thinking

Get the latest news and industry thoughts from Van Ameyde. With 75 years’ experience, you can count on our insights and knowledge to help you ensure your continuing success.  More articles

Uncategorized

1 min reading

Southwest Region Spotlight

Read More >

Digital transformation

2 min reading

Van Ameyde wins the Diamond Award at ITC DIA Amsterdam 2024

Read More >

Claims management

3 min reading

AI & Automation: Making Humans More ‘Human’ in the Claims Process

Read More >

Claims management

2 min reading

Exploring the Characteristics of Motor Liability Insurance Claims Handling in the Nordic Countries

Read More >

Claims management

4 min reading

How Van Ameyde is using technology to revolutionise the claims and repairs process for vehicle insurers

Read More >

Claims management

4 min reading

Cross-border claims: Getting personal about bodily injury claims in France and Italy

Read More >

Systems

1 min reading

(Zero)70 IT Services, part of Van Ameyde Systems, achieves BSI certificate extension

Read More >

Sustainability

10 min reading

How Van Ameyde Scandinavia is Driving Global Sustainability

Read More >

Claims management

4 min reading

Cross-border claims: Three key things to know about the UK legal system

Read More >

Organisation

3 min reading

The impact of the war in Ukraine on business and the insurance industry

Read More >

Organisation

2 min reading

Twentyfour, Rekon and Interschaden join forces in the field of loss adjustment sector

Read More >

Claims management

4 min reading

How to fulfill your claims promise… People, bots, AI?

Read More >

Digital transformation

4 min reading

Intrasurance Technology Services & (Zero)70 combine forces as Van Ameyde Systems

Read More >

Claims management

3 min reading

iptiQ EMEA P&C partners with Van Ameyde

Read More >

Partnerships

3 min reading

Van Ameyde participates in SEAsia Group

Read More >